News & Insights

BAAJA is the Chickens Coming Home to Roost: Why Environmental Lawyers Should Care About Permitting Delays

November 18, 2026 | by Neal McAliley
AI Generated Image

The proposed Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (“BAAJA”), if passed by Congress, would constitute one of the biggest changes to federal environmental laws in half a century. In the name of speeding permitting reviews, the legislation would make major changes to multiple bedrock statutes, including the National Environmental Policy Act, the Clean Water Act, Endangered Species Act, Clean Air Act, and National Historic Preservation Act.  BAAJA arguably would neuter laws such as NEPA by removing any practical remedy for violations, reduce the role of federal agencies by allowing more delegation to states, and restrict the grounds for objection to the issuance of federal approvals. Some of the proposed changes may qualify as simple streamlining of complex permit processes, but other changes would seem to reduce substantive environmental protections.

Unfortunately, there is a reason for the bipartisan support for the cause of permit reform: the time required to obtain many environmental approvals has gotten longer and longer over the past fifty years. In my practice, it typically takes many months or years to get federal approvals for any project that has more than a minimal level of complexity.  For example, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers can take more than a year to issue Clean Water Act Section 404 permits even for projects that have been vetted by state agencies. This is also true at state and local levels of government. In Miami-Dade County, Florida (where I live), it can take 9-12 months to get a local permit to trim a mangrove tree and two years to get a permit to conduct maintenance dredging of a residential canal. It did not take this long when I started my career, and the longer timeframes do not seem to correspond with improvements in the quality of environmental decision making.

Long approval timelines are becoming a threat to the environmental laws themselves.  Most of my clients do not object to having to get a permit, minimize environmental impacts, and pay for mitigation. But they all object to having to go through a seemingly endless process that delays their project, complicates their business planning, and adds little environmental benefit.  People who otherwise would support the environmental laws turn against them because permit delays cost them a lot of money for no apparent purpose. It is not a coincidence that the cause of environmental “permit reform” is one of the few areas of bipartisan agreement in Congress, because many people across the political spectrum are worn out by a sclerotic process.  

Modernizing slow, anachronistic environmental review processes would take the wind out of the sails of efforts to limit the substantive protections of the environmental laws. The reason most people want changes to NEPA are not the tiny percentage of controversial projects that end up in court, but the vast majority of projects where NEPA reviews take months or years despite there being relatively few environmental concerns. If most NEPA reviews were completed rapidly, then there would be many fewer supporters of efforts to limit judicial review of NEPA claims. I believe that the same is true of other environmental laws, at the federal, state and local level.   

There obviously are organizations that rely on slow, complicated processes to block projects they do not like. Viewed from the perspective of individual projects, a ponderous approval process may be a good thing depending on your point of view. But in the big picture, these slow permitting processes are breaking down the political consensus that helped pass the environmental laws in the first place. Most of the benefits that result from the environmental laws occur with the many less visible projects that generate little attention, and holding on to a broken system that helps delay a few big controversial projects puts the many small improvements at risk. Whatever happens to BAAJA, slow permitting systems at the federal, state, and local level need to be modernized so that they operate quickly and efficiently. A fast process does not need to result in bad outcomes.